Prebiotics and Probiotics: Hype or Help?

Beth Furness - Assistant Nutritionist

Exclusive Member Benefit

Our Healthy Balance magazine!
Find all editions in the app –tap 'More'.

(Free with membership)

When it comes to gut health, probiotic and prebiotic supplements and foods have become very popular within the health industry, but what exactly are they? And how can they actually benefit us? To break this down, I spoke with Registered Nutritionist, Dr. Janet Aylott, who shared valuable insights into what our members should know about them and their role in our digestive health!

Probiotics

Probiotics

What are they?

Probiotics are tiny microorganisms that live in our gut and appear to be beneficial to our digestive, and overall, health. They are live bacteria and other organisms such as yeasts, that live in harmony in our bodies helping to maintain a healthy balance of good (friendly) and more harmful bacteria in our gut.

You can find probiotics primarily in fermented foods like yoghurt, kefir, sauerkraut, kimchi, miso, tempeh, and kombucha. You might have seen foods such as yoghurt drinks that highlight their gut health benefits. The most common probiotics that are found in food products are known as Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium, however there are hundreds of different types.

How do probiotics work?

There’s a lot of evidence showing that probiotics can enhance the diversity of the gut microbiome, which refers to the variety of microorganisms living in our bodies. Since everyone’s gut microbiome is unique, it’s hard to pinpoint exactly which types of probiotics might be the best ones for us.

There is some research looking at the potential benefits of probiotics in gut health, conditions such as IBS and IBD but also the immune system, and the wider impact of the gut microbiome on mental health conditions such as depression. However, while evidence is growing, it’s still limited in terms of proof that probiotics work for everyone.

Another challenge with probiotics is that they need to be alive to be effective in the gut. They must survive the stomach’s acidity and temperature changes in the digestive system to reach the small and large intestine where they work best. Many of the brands of probiotics available in liquid or tablet form have done research showing that the probiotics survive this gut transit but not all probiotics have been tested.

Prebiotics

coffee 2

What are they?

Unlike probiotics, prebiotics aren’t live organisms, but they play a vital role in gut health by feeding the beneficial bacteria already living in our digestive system. Prebiotics are non-digestible fibres and compounds that stimulate the growth and activity of these friendly microorganisms, helping them thrive.

Prebiotics can be found in high-fibre foods such as bananas, onions, garlic, leeks, asparagus, artichokes, oats, and whole grains. Certain vegetables, legumes, and plant-based foods contain fibres known as inulin and fructooligosaccharides. Eating a wide variety of plant-based foods (fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, wholegrains) provides many different prebiotic components.

How do they benefit our health?

Because prebiotics serve as food for the ‘good’ bacteria in our gut, including prebiotic-rich foods in your diet can enhance the diversity of your gut microbiome. This, much like consuming probiotics, could positively affect your overall health.

One advantage of prebiotics over probiotics is that they don’t need to ‘survive’ the digestive process. Since they are simply fibres that nourish existing bacteria, they’re also often easy to incorporate into your daily diet.

Should you include probiotics and prebiotics in your diet?

Including both probiotics and prebiotics in your diet can be a beneficial way to improve the diversity of your gut microbiome. Dr. Aylott suggests that, where possible, consuming them through food sources is preferable to relying on supplements, as whole-foods offer additional nutrients and fibre that support overall health.

However, if you struggle to get enough probiotics through your diet alone, supplements can be a helpful option. Just make sure to choose products that have been tested for their ability to deliver live probiotics to your gut.

The takeaway

Both probiotics and prebiotics offer potential benefits for gut health, but their effectiveness can vary depending on individual circumstances. Whilst the science is still evolving, adding fermented foods and high-fibre plant-based foods to your diet can be an easy, natural way to support a healthy gut and overall wellbeing.

Nutritionist Beth Furness (ANutr), holding a BSc in Nutrition and Health, is deeply dedicated to applying evidence-based knowledge to all aspects of nutrition. Her passion lies in fostering healthy relationships with food, ensuring that everyone maintains a balanced and sustainable approach to nutrition.

This site uses cookies to personalise content and ads, provide social media features and analyse our traffic. Find out more about how we use cookies.

Choose which cookies you allow us to use. You can read more about our Cookie Policy in our Privacy Policy.